7 Comments
User's avatar
Erin Umberg's avatar

Just bought one of these for my mom few months ago! (Plan to borrow it from her :)

Alexander MacInnis's avatar

Is there a paper showing how the Chao trial with only 4 subjects in each of 2 arms produced a p value of 0.007 for one of the outcomes? Seems dubious.

Karin Dee's avatar

The treatment group improved while the control group deteriorated, producing a large difference in outcomes. However, your skepticism is justified. With only eight participants, and no sham control, I regard this as an interesting proof-of-concept study, not convincing evidence of clinical efficacy.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1089/photob.2018.4555

Ron Lane's avatar

I’ve been using the Neuronic Light since taking part in a NeuroShield Collective, now Phoenix study that showed a small improvement in memory, and also the affordable 40 hz light and sound kit Dr. Nick recommended. I jog while doing each, each lasting about an hour. My Tau 217 of .39 and memory deficit prod me to try almost anything that could help. The nasal component of the Vielight sounds interesting as better access to the hippocampus. The Memory Air device I use at night has made a slight improvement in the inosmia, through the varied scents knocking at the door of the hippocampus. I always look forward to reading what you write.

Karin Dee's avatar

Thanks Ron - I also use the Memory Air(bought end of August) and am still testing it before I write about the experience. With a ptau of .39, wouldn’t you be a great candidate for the SPINOZA trial?

Kim frache's avatar

Karin- thank you for your objective and well balanced review. I have been watching for these kinds of reviews in addition to any empirical evidence emerging from ongoing studies. It looks very promising, but I am not in a financial place to invest such a significant amount of money into such a device until the results are a bit more concrete.

Karin Dee's avatar

I certainly undestand Kim - the Vielight wasn’t cheap. What might be a good (much) lower cost option is the red light panel I wrote about here. I use mine more regularly than the Vielight. I lie in front of it about 10-15 minutes each day with the light hitting the crown of my head as shown in the post. https://www.apoe44.org/p/shedding-light-on-the-brain-red-light